英语 英语 日语 日语 韩语 韩语 法语 法语 德语 德语 西班牙语 西班牙语 意大利语 意大利语 阿拉伯语 阿拉伯语 葡萄牙语 葡萄牙语 越南语 越南语 俄语 俄语 芬兰语 芬兰语 泰语 泰语 泰语 丹麦语 泰语 对外汉语

法律英语:122 Is Proposition 8 Constitutional?

时间:2010-11-19 03:31来源:互联网 提供网友:fi1171   字体: [ ]
特别声明:本栏目内容均从网络收集或者网友提供,供仅参考试用,我们无法保证内容完整和正确。如果资料损害了您的权益,请与站长联系,我们将及时删除并致以歉意。
    (单词翻译:双击或拖选)

by Adam Freedman

Today’s topic:  Proposition 8, gay marriage, and the Constitution.

And now, your daily dose of legalese:  This article does not create an attorney-client relationship with any reader.  In other words, although I am a lawyer, I’m not your lawyer.  In fact, we barely know each other. If you need personalized legal advice, contact an attorney in your community.
The podcast edition of this article was sponsored by Go to Meeting.  With this meeting service, you can hold your meetings over the Internet and give presentations, product demos and training sessions right from your PC. For a free, 45 day trial, visit GoToMeeting.com/podcast.

Prop1 8 Suffers a Defeat in the Court
On August 3, 2010, a federal judge struck down California’s Proposition 8, which prohibited the Golden State from issuing marriage licenses2 to same-sex couples.  I’ll explain what the judge decided3--and why--and what’s next in the legal battle over gay marriage.
Round Two for Gay Marriage in California
Prop 8 was passed by California’s voters in November 2008.  It amended4 the California Constitution with the following sentence: “Only marriage between a man and a woman is valid5 or recognized in California.” 

Prop 8 was actually “round two” in California’s battle over gay marriage.  In November 2000, the voters of California adopted a similar initiative known as Proposition 22, or the California Defense6 of Marriage Act.   However, as I discuss in an earlier article, the California Supreme7 Court struck down Prop 22 on the grounds that it violated the California Constitution.
What Is the Perry Lawsuit8?
Prop 8 was intended to address that earlier decision striking down Prop 22 by amending9 the California Constitution itself.  A few months after the passage of Prop 8, a number of gay couples filed a lawsuit against Governor Schwarzenneger and various other state officials challenging the law.  The lawsuit is known as Perry v. Schwarzenneger.
What Did the Prop 8 Ruling Say?
On August 3, 2010, Federal District Judge Vaughn Walker issued his decision against Prop 8. The decision is 136 pages long, so I won’t be able to describe every detail.   But the quick and dirty summary is that California’s decision to restrict marriage to opposite-sex couples violates the Fourteenth Amendment10 of the US Constitution--and the US Constitution trumps11 the California constitution.
What Does the Fourteenth Amendment Say?
The Fourteenth Amendment is one of three amendments12 adopted after the Civil War to ensure that America’s newly-freed slaves would enjoy the full rights of citizenship13.  Over time, courts have extended the reach of the Fourteenth Amendment beyond racial equality. Judge Walker’s ruling, however, marks the first time a federal court has held that the Fourteenth Amendment provides gay couples with a right to get married. Here’s how the judge got there.
The Fourteenth Amendment and Gay Rights
The Fourteenth Amendment says that no state shall:
deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction14 the equal protection of the laws.
The first part of that sentence is known as the “Due Process Clause” and the second part is the “Equal Protection Clause.”  Both clauses played a role in this case.

Let’s first talk about the Due Process Clause. When government action places a burden on the exercise of a “fundamental right”--such as the right to privacy--then it can be challenged under the Due Process Clause.  Earlier precedents15 have established that the right to marry is a “fundamental right.”  But the question is whether that fundamental right is limited to opposite-sex couples?
Is Marriage a Fundamental Right?
In what is likely to be one of the more controversial aspects of his decision, Judge Walker held that “gender no longer forms an essential part of marriage.” In other words, the “fundamental right” to marry applies to any two consenting adults--gay or straight.   The judge then concluded that California has no “legitimate16 interest” in denying marriage to gay couples and, therefore, Prop 8 violates the Due Process Clause.
What Is the Equal Protection Clause?
As for the Equal Protection Clause, on its face, it requires that all persons be treated equally under the law.  In reality, however, many, many laws require that different categories of people receive different treatment. 

Think about it: various laws say things like people under 16 can’t drive a car; or people under 21 can’t drink alcohol, or that women can’t serve in combat units in the military.  Don’t those violate “equal protection?”  The key is that courts will generally uphold such laws as long as they have a rational basis.  Some laws, however, are held to a higher standard--known as “strict scrutiny”--if they are found to target a “suspect class,” that is, a group that has suffered a history of unequal treatment.
The Equal Protection Clause and Gay Marriage
Judge Walker held that Prop 8 discriminates17 against gay individuals on the basis of both sex and sexual orientation--by denying them the right to choose a marital18 partner.  He then stated that Prop 8 violates the Equal Protection Clause because it is not rationally related to any legitimate government end.  The judge also said that laws such as Prop 8 should be treated to “strict scrutiny” because gays constitute a “suspect class.”  The court’s language is potentially significant because no federal court has held that gays and lesbians constitute a “suspect class” under the Equal Protection Clause.  However, because the court’s decision did not actually depend on using “strict scrutiny,” that language is not an official part of the court’s holding.

One interesting aspect of this case is that California already allows gay couples to enter into so-called domestic partnerships19, which provide essentially20 the same rights and obligations as traditional marriage.  However, the Court held that domestic partnerships don’t solve the Constitutional problems because domestic partnerships “do not provide the same social meaning as marriage.”   
What’s Next for Gay Marriage?
Judge Walker’s ruling is not the end of the story--the issue of gay marriage may well be coming to an appellate court near you.  The Prop 8 lawsuit is already being appealed to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals and is virtually certain to end up in the Supreme Court. 

Judge Walker’s ruling does not even mean that gay marriage will immediately resume in California--the Ninth Circuit has decided that Prop 8 will remain in effect until the current appeal is resolved.  Nor does it mean that other states must recognize California same-sex marriages.  The federal Defense of Marriage Act prohibits that.  Having said that, the Defense of Marriage Act itself is being challenged in--you guessed it--a lawsuit; this one originated in Massachusetts.

The coming months and years will be a fascinating time for the legal definition of “marriage.”  As for me, I kind of like the Chinese man who got around the whole problem a few years ago by marrying himself.  When asked why he did it, he simply said “this marriage makes me whole again.”

Thank you for reading Legal Lad’s Quick and Dirty Tips for a More Lawful21 Life.

You can send questions and comments to.............Please note that doing so will not create an attorney-client relationship and will be used for the purposes of this article only.
 


点击收听单词发音收听单词发音  

1 prop qR2xi     
vt.支撑;n.支柱,支撑物;支持者,靠山
参考例句:
  • A worker put a prop against the wall of the tunnel to keep it from falling.一名工人用东西支撑住隧道壁好使它不会倒塌。
  • The government does not intend to prop up declining industries.政府无意扶持不景气的企业。
2 licenses 9d2fccd1fa9364fe38442db17bb0cb15     
n.执照( license的名词复数 )v.批准,许可,颁发执照( license的第三人称单数 )
参考例句:
  • Drivers have ten days' grace to renew their licenses. 驾驶员更换执照有10天的宽限期。 来自《现代汉英综合大词典》
  • Jewish firms couldn't get import or export licenses or raw materials. 犹太人的企业得不到进出口许可证或原料。 来自辞典例句
3 decided lvqzZd     
adj.决定了的,坚决的;明显的,明确的
参考例句:
  • This gave them a decided advantage over their opponents.这使他们比对手具有明显的优势。
  • There is a decided difference between British and Chinese way of greeting.英国人和中国人打招呼的方式有很明显的区别。
4 Amended b2abcd9d0c12afefe22fd275996593e0     
adj. 修正的 动词amend的过去式和过去分词
参考例句:
  • He asked to see the amended version. 他要求看修订本。
  • He amended his speech by making some additions and deletions. 他对讲稿作了些增删修改。
5 valid eiCwm     
adj.有确实根据的;有效的;正当的,合法的
参考例句:
  • His claim to own the house is valid.他主张对此屋的所有权有效。
  • Do you have valid reasons for your absence?你的缺席有正当理由吗?
6 defense AxbxB     
n.防御,保卫;[pl.]防务工事;辩护,答辩
参考例句:
  • The accused has the right to defense.被告人有权获得辩护。
  • The war has impacted the area with military and defense workers.战争使那个地区挤满了军队和防御工程人员。
7 supreme PHqzc     
adj.极度的,最重要的;至高的,最高的
参考例句:
  • It was the supreme moment in his life.那是他一生中最重要的时刻。
  • He handed up the indictment to the supreme court.他把起诉书送交最高法院。
8 lawsuit A14xy     
n.诉讼,控诉
参考例句:
  • They threatened him with a lawsuit.他们以诉讼威逼他。
  • He was perpetually involving himself in this long lawsuit.他使自己无休止地卷入这场长时间的诉讼。
9 amending 3b6cbbbfac3f73caf84c14007b7a5bdc     
改良,修改,修订( amend的现在分词 ); 改良,修改,修订( amend的第三人称单数 )( amends的现在分词 )
参考例句:
  • Amending acts in 1933,1934, and 1935 attempted to help honest debtors rehabilitate themselves. 一九三三年,一九三四年和一九三五年通过的修正案是为了帮助诚实的债务人恢复自己的地位。
  • Two ways were used about the error-amending of contour curve. 采用两种方法对凸轮轮廓曲线进行了修正。
10 amendment Mx8zY     
n.改正,修正,改善,修正案
参考例句:
  • The amendment was rejected by 207 voters to 143.这项修正案以207票对143票被否决。
  • The Opposition has tabled an amendment to the bill.反对党已经就该议案提交了一项修正条款。
11 trumps 22c5470ebcda312e395e4d85c40b03f7     
abbr.trumpets 喇叭;小号;喇叭形状的东西;喇叭筒v.(牌戏)出王牌赢(一牌或一墩)( trump的过去式 );吹号公告,吹号庆祝;吹喇叭;捏造
参考例句:
  • On the day of the match the team turned up trumps. 比赛那天该队出乎意料地获得胜利。 来自《简明英汉词典》
  • Every time John is late getting home he trumps up some new excuse. 每次约翰晚回家都会编造个新借口。 来自《简明英汉词典》
12 amendments 39576081718792f25ceae20f3bb99b43     
(法律、文件的)改动( amendment的名词复数 ); 修正案; 修改; (美国宪法的)修正案
参考例句:
  • The committee does not adequately consult others when drafting amendments. 委员会在起草修正案时没有充分征求他人的意见。
  • Please propose amendments and addenda to the first draft of the document. 请对这个文件的初稿提出修改和补充意见。
13 citizenship AV3yA     
n.市民权,公民权,国民的义务(身份)
参考例句:
  • He was born in Sweden,but he doesn't have Swedish citizenship.他在瑞典出生,但没有瑞典公民身分。
  • Ten years later,she chose to take Australian citizenship.十年后,她选择了澳大利亚国籍。
14 jurisdiction La8zP     
n.司法权,审判权,管辖权,控制权
参考例句:
  • It doesn't lie within my jurisdiction to set you free.我无权将你释放。
  • Changzhou is under the jurisdiction of Jiangsu Province.常州隶属江苏省。
15 precedents 822d1685d50ee9bc7c3ee15a208b4a7e     
引用单元; 范例( precedent的名词复数 ); 先前出现的事例; 前例; 先例
参考例句:
  • There is no lack of precedents in this connection. 不乏先例。
  • He copied after bad precedents. 他仿效恶例。
16 legitimate L9ZzJ     
adj.合法的,合理的,合乎逻辑的;v.使合法
参考例句:
  • Sickness is a legitimate reason for asking for leave.生病是请假的一个正当的理由。
  • That's a perfectly legitimate fear.怀有这种恐惧完全在情理之中。
17 discriminates 6e196af54d58787174643156dbf5a037     
分别,辨别,区分( discriminate的第三人称单数 ); 歧视,有差别地对待
参考例句:
  • The new law discriminates against lower-paid workers. 这条新法律歧视低工资的工人。
  • One test governs state legislation that discriminates against interstate commerce. 一个检验约束歧视州际商业的州立法。 来自英汉非文学 - 环境法 - 环境法
18 marital SBixg     
adj.婚姻的,夫妻的
参考例句:
  • Her son had no marital problems.她的儿子没有婚姻问题。
  • I regret getting involved with my daughter's marital problems;all its done is to bring trouble about my ears.我后悔干涉我女儿的婚姻问题, 现在我所做的一切将给我带来无穷的烦恼。
19 partnerships ce2e6aff420d72bbf56e8077be344bc9     
n.伙伴关系( partnership的名词复数 );合伙人身份;合作关系
参考例句:
  • Partnerships suffer another major disadvantage: decision-making is shared. 合伙企业的另一主要缺点是决定要由大家来作。 来自英汉非文学 - 政府文件
  • It involved selling off limited partnerships. 它涉及到售出有限的合伙权。 来自辞典例句
20 essentially nntxw     
adv.本质上,实质上,基本上
参考例句:
  • Really great men are essentially modest.真正的伟人大都很谦虚。
  • She is an essentially selfish person.她本质上是个自私自利的人。
21 lawful ipKzCt     
adj.法律许可的,守法的,合法的
参考例句:
  • It is not lawful to park in front of a hydrant.在消火栓前停车是不合法的。
  • We don't recognised him to be the lawful heir.我们不承认他为合法继承人。
本文本内容来源于互联网抓取和网友提交,仅供参考,部分栏目没有内容,如果您有更合适的内容,欢迎点击提交分享给大家。
------分隔线----------------------------
顶一下
(2)
100%
踩一下
(0)
0%
最新评论 查看所有评论
发表评论 查看所有评论
请自觉遵守互联网相关的政策法规,严禁发布色情、暴力、反动的言论。
评价:
表情:
验证码:
听力搜索
推荐频道
论坛新贴